Florian Grunert & Michael Niekamp: A Non-Attribution-Dilemma and its Impact on Legal Regulation and other Rational Strategies

Michael Niekamp and Florian Grunert have published an paper titled:"A Non-Attribution-Dilemma and its Impact on Legal Regulation and other Rational Strategies"

You can read the abstract here and download the full paper if you want to.

A general challenge of cyberwar lies in the field of legal regulation. This paper analyses the systematic role of the nonattribution-problem with regard to the possibility of rational legal regulation.

Firstly we provide a conceptual specification of nonattribution. Secondly, referring to a classical definition of war and a sound principle of self-defense, we provide a logical clarification of these terms for cases of non-attribution.

Afterwards we argue that any attempt to rational legal regulation will lead to a serious non-attribution-dilemma, which consists either in a reductio ad absurdum of the category of war and a sound principle of self-defense or the indistinguishability of a state of regulation and anarchy.

However, the existence of this non-attribution-dilemma has no impact on the possibility of rational deterrence through a threat of retaliation, which in turn might lead to a complete prudential dilemma.

A Non-Attribution-Dilemma and its Impact on Legal Regulation and other Rational Strategies by Michael Niekamp and Florian Grunert

Keywords: legal regulation; non-attribution-dilemma; prudential-dilemma; impossibility

Download the full paper by Florian Grunert & Michael Niekamp

Download the full paper here:

http://www.study4cyberwar.com/images/attribution_niekamp_grunert.pdf

Published by:

CWZ's picture

Name
Reza Rafati

Information
I am the founder of Cyberwarzone.com and I focus on sharing and collecting relevant cyberconflict news., The goal of Cyberwarzone is to provide the world a portal with global cyberwar information. The effort in getting this cyberwarfare information is hard. But as the internet is growing we need to get an global cyberwar & cybercrime monitoring system., By the people and for the people. We will be gathering information about Cybercrime, Cyberwarfare and hacking. LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/pub/reza-rafati-%E2%99%82/1a/98b/197

Country
The Netherlands

My website
Cyberwarzone.com

Twitter:
http://twitter.com/#!/cyberwarzonecom